In my previous article, How a single click can destroy trillions, I talked about the recent coup/heist that Circle-Of-Two <CO2> was subjected to, and the damage it inflicted. If you haven’t read that article, you should consider doing so.

In this follow-up article, I would like to talk about some of the factors that make such a coup possible, and potential ways it could have been prevented. I would like to focus a little on the ways EVE Online limits options to rule alliances, and the vulnerabilities this system innately possesses. (note: I’m nowhere near a specialist on alliance management. Feel free to correct me if I’m wrong about something).

Let us take a look at the way the CO2 alliance had set up its space empire, and the influence it had. At the moment of the coup, the CO2 alliance consisted of around 4000 pilots spread across 75 corporations. These corporations were all lead by their individual leaders, the CEOs. The direction of the alliance was determined by gigX (the head of the alliance), with the support of a small group of subleaders from different corporations. This is a fairly normal setup in most large corporations and alliances. The CEO is considered the most important player who can control all functions related to alliance management. The subleaders serve as backup leadership, to take away some of the CEO’s workload, or take over when he isn’t available. In large alliances, these subleaders are almost a necessity, as the amount of work it takes to run a large alliance is quite sizable. This is especially so if the CEO wants the occasional night’s rest. Normally, these subleaders can be appointed to perform specific tasks. The accountant (who has access to all corporation wallets, assets and can pay bills), Communications Officer (can modify messages of the day, and com channels), Diplomat (who manages the contact lists and the standings towards other alliances) and plenty of others. This allows subleaders to influence specific fields of work that they have been allocated. If a subleader is a ‘jack of all trades’ and seems trustworthy enough, the CEO can assign them the Director role, which means the player receives pretty much all other roles. In practice, this means he becomes equal in power to the CEO, having access to all functions and assets. The only exception to this is the inability to allocate or remove the role of director.

In the case of CO2, there was a small group of these directors, including The Judge (the man behind the coup). When the coup was executed, he used his leadership roles to steal valuables and change ownership of citadels. This may make you wonder: why did nobody stop him? Well that has everything to do with the efficiency of management in EVE. In our real world every large project takes time. A house changing ownership takes weeks, money transfers a few minutes, and unloading cargo takes hours. Looking at a real coup it usually takes several days to occupy essential buildings, assets and media channels. While in EVE, robbing an alliance blind is a matter of a few quick financial transactions and then clicking and dragging stacks of assets to your personal hangar. They are hardly time-consuming actions. If any of the ‘subleaders’ would have been aware the heist was in progress, they would only have a few seconds/minutes for damage-control (safe assets that weren’t stolen yet). The only one who could have truly stop the process was gigX, with the power to remove The Judge’s director-role. But at the moment of the coup, he was asleep. This gave the thief the few moments of free reign he needed.

Another thing in favor of The Judge was the allocation of structures in CO2 space. In some alliances, individual corporations are allowed to deploy and manage their own citadels and stations. This allows them to freely run their business, independent of alliance leadership, resulting in an area of space where the structures are owned by dozens of different entities, all under the umbrella of the alliance. The problem of such a system is, that if one of these corporations ‘goes rogue’, the alliance could lose stations and citadels. Each individual corporation leader could compromise the safety of the entire region. To counteract this risk, the CO2 alliance gave the ownership of all structures to one corporation: the executor corp, SRBI Holding, which was owned by gigX himself. By doing this, the security of the space-stations didn’t rely on the whims of dozens of corporation CEOs, but on a small group of directors that where selected for the job. This system is effective, for the most part. However, the major problem lies on who/how the alliance leader places trust. The Judge had earned gigX’s trust after more than 5 years of co-operation and friendship. In hindsight, however, this trust was poorly placed. It was essential to the fact that he was able to abuse his power, without being reigned in. In the end, a misplaced sense of trustworthiness gave an ill-willed person access to everything he could dream of, allowing him to pull of one of the greatest heists in EVE’s history.

Of course, many other factors made this coup so effective, but we will not be looking at them in this article. Here are some items that crossed my mind.

There are not many ways to set up an alliance’s leadership in EVE. You could basically look at leaderships of alliances as a dictatorial system. There is a single almighty person, who controls all the power, and can make decisions as he pleases. The addition of alliance directors only serve as ‘additional almighties’ that are supposed to cooperate. But as current events show, there is nothing stopping them if they don’t wish to toe the line. In the real world, most countries have recognized that such a method of government isn’t desirable. Dividing the power is essential to keep the ruling class in check. Many of those governments added filters to keep the nation out of trouble. A congress, senate or similar institution has the simple function to make-up/aprove good plans and block the bad ones.  These systems make sure that a single nutjob’s bad ideas can’t do too much harm. Unfortunately, in EVE online there is no option to add such filters, never mind install a fully functional democracy. Of course a good chat among leaders can sort out some stuff, or a ‘straw poll’ among members can work as a referendum. I could add several pages about the hundreds of different ways real-life corporations and countries are run which would be better/safer than the current system in EVE. Given that CCP doesn’t give us any options to apply them, I feel talking about them would be a waste of time. In EVE we always end up with a single person being able to push the buttons, thus overriding any democratic decision-making.

With that in mind, I’ll speculate a little about some other methods to limit a single person’s power within an alliance in EVE. If a person chooses to ‘go bad’ it would be safer to control the amount of influence he/she has. The main risk-factor is in the director role. If an alliance CEO would only give each leader 1-2 functions, there would only be 1-2 leadership aspects at risk with any one leader. For example: if the Judge would only have had the accountant role, he would have been able to steal a trillion in ISK and assets, but wouldn’t have been able to transfer the citadels. That would still be a harsh loss, but not nearly as bad. The problem with this is obvious; if a leader has only 1-2 functions, there need to be more leaders appointed, who may not be available. additionally, more security treats are introduced as the pool of leaders with access increases.

In the CO2 heist, all valuables where located in a single citadel (the Keepstar in 68FT). The Judge could take control of this citadel, and by transferring the ownership this station he cut all pilots off from their assets. A high-impact move. With a little more investment of ISK and time, it would be possible to setup a group of citadels, which would allow splitting of ship-caches and inhabitants, thereby spreading risk. In order to keep these citadels safe, they would need to be controlled by multiple different people. If one of the responsible leaders rebelled, there would still be a few other citadels with a good supply of ships and pilots. As mentioned before, with this solution the amount of players that need to be trusted grows, which is itself a security risk.

Over a trillion in assets and ISK in a single place, accessible to multiple persons. Now that’s like throwing a steak in a dog-pen and telling them in a stern, command voice to “stay”. They may be the most loyal dogs in the world, but eventually one them will take a bite, and who can blame them when they do? On how many occasions would a director actually need access to such an amount of wealth. To me the obvious solution would be to lock some of that money away, for example in the CEO-wallet. If somebody is ill-willed, they would only be able to access the limited amount in the alliance’s wallet. With hard assets this is more difficult to achieve but is not impossible. This would have limited the theft to a certain extent.

As you’ve probably understood from my ranting above I cannot give you a real solution to protect an alliance from an ‘inside job’, I can only provide some ideas. The work of managing a large alliance is just too large for a single person. Work needs to be divided in order to manage, and the only basis for doing so is trust. As recent events show, trusting somebody doesn’t make them worthy of that trust. This makes it hard to choose who should receive power within an alliance. If many people are given a limited amount of power, there are a lot of smaller security risks. If a few people are given large amounts of power, the alliance is at risk of a major sabotage. Neither of which is preferable. More stable ways to divide power are simply not supported by the game – CCP, please consider this. With my limited insights, without CCP’s involvement I don’t see a reasonable solution to this conundrum.

Do you have any ideas about alliance security? How is your alliance setup? Leave a comment if you have a good idea. Maybe together we can find a better solution that could benefit us all.

1,099 Comments

  1. Very neat article.Really thank you! Fantastic.

    May 14, 2019 at 05:48 Reply
  2. Now it is time to decide your specific investments.

    May 14, 2019 at 08:05 Reply
  3. There are thousands of blogs that needs discuss them. What is the intent of blog site remarks?

    May 14, 2019 at 23:29 Reply
  4. Thanks again for the blog article.Really thank you! Fantastic.

    May 15, 2019 at 06:03 Reply
  5. Usually I do not read post on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to check out and do it! Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thank you, quite nice article.

    May 15, 2019 at 10:38 Reply
  6. I don’tdo not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was goodgreat. I don’tdo not know who you are but definitelycertainly you areyou’re going to a famous blogger if you are notaren’t already 😉 Cheers!

    May 15, 2019 at 13:39 Reply
  7. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great

    May 15, 2019 at 13:48 Reply
  8. I’m not sure whyexactly why but this blogsiteweb sitewebsiteweblog is loading extremelyincrediblyvery slow for me. Is anyone else having this issueproblem or is it a problemissue on my end? I’ll check back laterlater on and see if the problem still exists.

    May 16, 2019 at 00:27 Reply
  9. Oh my goodness! a wonderful post dude. Thanks a lot Even so We’re experiencing issue with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to register for it. Possibly there is anybody getting identical rss dilemma? Anybody who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

    May 16, 2019 at 00:31 Reply
  10. Going through your brilliant blog has surely supplied me
    personally with just the details that I actually needed. We have been undertaking
    study upon this matter for some time, and it has taken a long time to find a blog page that delivers all the information i will need.

    I search toward studying more weblogs authored by
    you in the foreseeable future, and will certainly
    search here first the next time I currently have another fact-finding project. https://massage-at-home-nj.blogspot.com/2010/04/at-home-massage-for-first-time-nj.html

    May 16, 2019 at 04:44 Reply
  11. Upon reflection, I thought this blog is timely and relevant.
    Thank you very much for penning this trove of information; if more writers wrote time-worthy and intelligent
    musings, I think we’d all understand life better. To me, I know might focus more on eating well and keeping fit and alive and free from being always on the computer or cell phone screen. Go outside!!
    (and not being glued to the cell phone all the while, either)
    and living life in full appreciation of Nature, helps people feel
    sane and feeling joyous. Thinking about important topics is likewise an experience that can aid us know
    ourselves. http://teil.cc/24Mwl

    May 16, 2019 at 09:16 Reply
  12. Your site has provided me personally with simply the details that I required.

    I have recently been doing analysis upon this subject matter for a
    while, and this seems to have taken a very long while
    to discover a blog that delivers all the details i want.
    I search forward to examining more blogs authored by you later on, and might start
    looking here 1st when I just currently have a research study. http://Www.Prime50plus.co.uk/site-redirect.php?bannerid=137&redirectlink=https://www.photovoltaicforums.com%2Fnode%2F2%2Ftrack

    May 16, 2019 at 13:42 Reply
  13. Your site has provided me personally with simply the details that I required.
    I have recently been doing analysis upon this subject matter for a while, and this seems to have taken a very long while to
    discover a blog that delivers all the details i want.
    I search forward to examining more blogs authored
    by you later on, and might start looking here 1st
    when I just currently have a research study. http://Www.Prime50plus.co.uk/site-redirect.php?bannerid=137&redirectlink=https://www.photovoltaicforums.com%2Fnode%2F2%2Ftrack

    May 16, 2019 at 13:43 Reply
  14. This blog is extremely good. How was it made ?

    May 16, 2019 at 17:49 Reply
  15. This web site definitely has all of the info I needed about this subject and didn at know who to ask.

    May 17, 2019 at 20:54 Reply
  16. Very nice write-up. I absolutely love this website. Thanks!

    May 18, 2019 at 00:28 Reply
  17. SUN TZU

    May 18, 2019 at 07:08 Reply
  18. It’s a shamepity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainlywithout a doubtcertainlydefinitely donate to this superbbrilliantfantasticexcellentoutstanding blog! I supposeguess for now i’ll settle for book-markingbookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to freshbrand newnew updates and will talk aboutshare this blogsitewebsite with my Facebook group. ChatTalk soon!

    May 18, 2019 at 08:49 Reply
  19. I Will Supply A List Of Business Phone Numbers http://bit.ly/2YvPumT

    May 18, 2019 at 15:48 Reply
  20. I cannot consider everything we concern ourselves with
    in our lives makes a difference. Constantly spent thinking about the assorted things that people confront every
    single and every working day is going to be undoubtedly
    necessary, as no other woman will probably confront existence for
    us. I feel that citizens need to be even more sane. Research is fantastic,
    however, so much of whatever you might know about is indeed
    abstract. Having a cup of coffee is a zen activity that takes one back
    again to the present moment. We need to be more in the
    here and today, without being overcome by existence
    and the drama we face each day. http://www.alaskaguidedhunt.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=www.kimpado.altervista.org%2Fguestbook%2Fguestbook.php

    May 18, 2019 at 23:16 Reply
  21. And that is an investment danger worth taking.

    May 19, 2019 at 08:14 Reply
  22. Wow, great blog article.Much thanks again.

    May 20, 2019 at 08:45 Reply
  23. The best of young hot girls. These Babe porn videos are highlighting the beauty of nude teen bitches. Dirty nude babes want to cum with a horny fireworks. Super horny babe porn videos are here to set your lustful pants on real horny wild fire.

    May 20, 2019 at 12:12 Reply
  24. YORUMLAR

    May 20, 2019 at 13:02 Reply
  25. I am sure this articlepostpiece of writingparagraph has touched all the internet userspeopleviewersvisitors, its really really nicepleasantgoodfastidious articlepostpiece of writingparagraph on building up new blogweblogwebpagewebsiteweb site.

    May 20, 2019 at 14:12 Reply
  26. You have brought up a very good points , thanks for the post.

    May 20, 2019 at 14:31 Reply
  27. i need some ideas for a blog site. i already do poems as well as studies on it however i wan na talk about something.

    May 20, 2019 at 19:02 Reply
  28. thank you web site admin

    May 20, 2019 at 23:03 Reply
  29. Backlinks that work Rank your website or Social meadia page fast and drive traffic. Full writeup on Black Hat World http://bit.ly/2w7wZZN

    May 21, 2019 at 02:58 Reply
  30. Thank you ever so for you blog.Really thank you! Much obliged.

    May 21, 2019 at 13:24 Reply
  31. I wasI’m very pleasedextremely pleasedpretty pleasedvery happymore than happyexcited to findto discoverto uncover this websitethis sitethis web sitethis great sitethis page. I wantedI want toI need to to thank you for yourfor ones time for thisjust for thisdue to thisfor this particularly wonderfulfantastic read!! I definitely enjoyedlovedappreciatedlikedsavoredreally liked every little bit ofbit ofpart of it and Iand i also have you bookmarkedsaved as a favoritebook-markedbook markedsaved to fav to check outto seeto look at new stuffthingsinformation on yourin your blogwebsiteweb sitesite.

    May 21, 2019 at 14:05 Reply
  32. HurrahWow! FinallyAt lastAfter allIn the end I got a blogweblogwebpagewebsiteweb site from where I canbe able toknow how tobe capable of reallyactuallyin facttrulygenuinely takegetobtain usefulhelpfulvaluable datainformationfacts regardingconcerning my study and knowledge.

    May 22, 2019 at 00:05 Reply
  33. You shouldYou ought toYou need to take part inbe a part of a contest for one of the bestof the greatestof the finestof the highest qualityof the most useful blogssiteswebsites on the webon the interneton the netonline. I willI am going toI most certainly willI’m going to recommendhighly recommend this sitethis websitethis blogthis web site!

    May 22, 2019 at 09:38 Reply
  34. You are my breathing in, I own few web logs and occasionally run out from to brand.

    May 22, 2019 at 12:22 Reply
  35. Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you writing this write-up and the rest of the website is also very good.

    May 22, 2019 at 13:25 Reply
  36. HiWhat’s upHi thereHello, this weekend is nicepleasantgoodfastidious fordesigned forin favor ofin support of me, becausesinceasfor the reason that this timeoccasionpoint in timemoment i am reading this greatenormousimpressivewonderfulfantastic informativeeducational articlepostpiece of writingparagraph here at my homehouseresidence.

    May 22, 2019 at 23:59 Reply
  37. It isIt’s appropriateperfectthe best time to make some plans for the future and it isit’s time to be happy. I haveI’ve read this post and if I could I want towish todesire to suggest you fewsome interesting things or advicesuggestionstips. PerhapsMaybe you couldcan write next articles referring to this article. I want towish todesire to read moreeven more things about it!

    May 23, 2019 at 10:08 Reply
  38. instagram pornosu twitter pornosu turk porno izle

    May 23, 2019 at 15:29 Reply
  39. I need to know just how to watch my messages or talk about other individuals blogs. Is there anywhere I could go to obtain a checklist of all my blog posts?. Any kind of aid appreciated.

    May 23, 2019 at 22:12 Reply
  40. Really appreciate you sharing this post.Really thank you!

    May 23, 2019 at 22:35 Reply
  41. This is a topic that isthat’swhich is close tonear to my heart… CheersMany thanksBest wishesTake careThank you! WhereExactly where are your contact details though?

    May 23, 2019 at 23:27 Reply
  42. hayvanli sikis travesti pornuosu

    May 24, 2019 at 15:21 Reply
  43. Muchos Gracias for your post. Much obliged.

    May 24, 2019 at 15:36 Reply
  44. Erotic porn videos featuring tasteful yet hot action. Nude girls don’t show too much, it’s all real. Hot softcore act is all about passionate and tender making out and fooling around. Sweat softcore porn videos are incredibly sweet and making you extremely turned on.

    May 24, 2019 at 15:38 Reply
  45. HiWhat’s upHi thereHello Dear, are you reallyactuallyin facttrulygenuinely visiting this websiteweb sitesiteweb page regularlydailyon a regular basis, if so thenafter thatafterward you will definitelyabsolutelywithout doubt takegetobtain nicepleasantgoodfastidious experienceknowledgeknow-how.

    May 24, 2019 at 23:25 Reply
  46. Do you want 1000’s of links like this from only $10’s ? http://bit.ly/BHWBacklinks

    May 25, 2019 at 12:49 Reply
  47. Do you 1000’s of links like this from only $10’s ?https://amzn.to/30SuXLk

    May 25, 2019 at 18:09 Reply
  48. Some truly nice and utilitarian info on this site, too I believe the pattern has got excellent features.

    May 25, 2019 at 20:31 Reply
  49. HelloHey thereHeyGood dayHowdyHi thereHello thereHi! Do you know if they make any plugins to protectsafeguard against hackers? I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any suggestionsrecommendationstips?

    May 26, 2019 at 14:04 Reply

Leave a Reply