PLEX Has Zero Elasticity- The Runaway Horse

One of the greatest strengths to Eve Online (that may not be frequently apparent to new players) is that you can pay for your subscription with in game currency. For average players who may be school aged or can’t afford ‘another subscription’ this is perfect. The unfortunate realization with this fact is that the in game currency used to pay for account subscriptions (coequally known as PLEX) has nearly zero price elasticity of demand. As the price of PLEX increases or decreases the demand for it is hardly affected. As a result, the prices of PLEX have been consistently rising (year after year).

PLEX Is an Extremely Liquid Market.

It has been estimated that the average volume of PLEX traded on the market is close to three trillion isk per day. It has been some time since CCP has released official figures on the amount of PLEX usage. In December of 2010 CCP reported that nearly 100,000 subscriptions a month were being paid with PLEX (this would equate to over 60 trillion isk in today’s market. At the time, PLEX was equated to account
for roughly one fourth of all consumer purchases for the month (note that this takes into account players that do not use PLEX to fund accounts as well).

In our current situation in eve, this places the figures for PLEX in the tens of trillions of isk per month (even disregarding the likelihood of inflation and the growth of PLEX usage over the last two years).

Recall that a significant amount of the purchasing power made by the average player goes into subscribing for their account.

Supply and Demand

The most basic tenants of Supply and Demand are that as the price of a product increase, the demand will decrease proportionately. There are a few situations in which this may not be the case such as when substitutions are involved. When corn prices across the globe start to climb consumers may switch to a substitute product (such as wheat). This is generally true in practical applications of any economic product. When a substitute exists, consumers will switch to the alternative product.

Consumer Budget Constraints

Many of you are probably wondering, “What does the average consumer do when prices rise, but there is no ‘alternative product?” The consumers generally will be forced to adhere to their budget constraint. In other words, for the Eve online player that cannot afford to pay real life money for their single (or in some cases- multiple) accounts, they will still purchase PLEX. The effect of budget constraints will generally force some players to either:

a.) Cut into their profitability on isk making accounts
b.) Spend less money on ships and fittings
c.) Sell off non profitable or ‘unused accounts’ (This has negative effects on ‘demand’)

Traditionally PLEX prices have risen when capsuleers are faced with a large raise in purchasing power. These rises in PLEX prices have traditionally coincided with significant changes to the game (Respawning Anomalies, Incursions, Faction Warfare, Mining Changes). Who can know what the magical PLEX equilibrium price may be. This winter, we may just find out (again).

< /b>CCP Screenshot of the Jita Market on PLEX Prices. Showing a 1 Year Average, Retrieved on 10/10/12

-Zarofdium

Send us Intel/Corrections via dropbox or shoot us an e-mail

Send us Intel/Corrections via dropbox or shoot us an e-mail

  • http://evenews24.com riverini

    My main theory with PLEX is that making isk with FW is so easy people stopped buying plex with their RL cash and started taking up the dwindling stock of PLEX in the market, apart from that I am pretty sure a ton of PLEX was brought in preparation for that $10,000 tournament Own3d is organizing.

    • Corteztk

      I agree with your main theory about too many people making easy isk and either A) not buying and selling plex themselves or B) Actually plexing their own accounts with their tons of loot

      I would have to disagree with the idea though that this tournament will have a meaningful effect on plex prices, it's not that many plex and it's a one time thing, i don't imagine it could possibly effect plex prices that much.

      • dani

        I don't know how long have you played eve, but you are wrong.

        Every promo involving PLEX so far, had its impact on the PLEX prices.
        CCP Do control the PLEX market!
        Here are the facts:
        1. Lets make plex movable
        /every plex destroyed in the game is 15$ gift for CCP /
        2. Let offer this promo video cards. You can buy them for PLEX!
        / Do you think, that anyone with enough cash in his poket is going to spend it on PLEXes so he can then buy a Graphics card ? /
        3. Power of two program. You pay 3x PLEX and you get 180 days play time for new account.

        ..
        Even events were CCP asked us to contribute in Saving the word. "Donate a PLEX" etc.
        .
        Every one of those things has its effect on the PLEX prices.

        I agree with Riverini's Theory.
        10k $ Tournament is Different from the Alliance Tournament. There real money to be made here :)
        and Again, if you think that someone is going to convert $ to get plexes for this, you are wrong.

        About the FW isk. If the impact on the isk value is so big, we should of seen a number of rare items that you can not get from faction lp stores to go up as well.

        • Corteztk

          I'm sorry Dani but I'm not wrong. You seem to have inferred quite a bit about my beliefs from a very short paragraph I wrote. The plex market plex"s 100k accounts per month approximately. That is 1.2million plex a year. Every year there is one tournament. This year there are two.

          A tournament takes up maybe 500 to 2000 plex. That is a rounding error in a 1.2 million plex market. So my point is that a one (or two) time shock that small will have no meaningful long term effect on the plex market. It may have a small effect for one or two days but not on the long term. Economics 101 my friend I can recommend you a nice school.

    • doublefacepalm.

      naa i start to belive the old tale about a PLEX cartell driving the prices up … =)

    • Mkhat

      correction, that is a hypothesis..not a theory

      i'm just saying

      • http://evenews24.com riverini

        No it is a theory, because you have never head of conspiracy hypothesists, have you? B)

        • mararinn

          Conspiracy Theorists are mutters who do not understand critical thinking or scientific method.

          A theory is a hypothesis that has been tested and has a large amount of supporting evidence.

          A hypothesis is a testable prediction about what will or will not happen in certain circumstances.

          If your “theory” is unprovable, it is not a theory, it is not a hypothesis, but it may well be bullshit.

          But in this circumstance, I agree with riverini's bullshit. We have to way of proving that the price rise is due to FW+Tournament, but we can observe what happens to PLEX prices after next weekend when the tournament auction happens. If tournament bids were in fact a great driver for PLEX prices, I expect to see prices drop significantly over that weekend.

          • -a- pet

            until i go buy 50 plex because i can to mess with peoples predictions

        • Random Miner

          nice

  • John Douche

    Oh noes, it is a pony!

    Seriously, what did I just read?

  • LOL.

    your analysis of supply / demand is flawed. even if you look at your screenshot you can see the up and downs that have been there – despite you picking a specifically steady year (this one) where no huge alliances have been stocking up on super capitals (as seen on the much higher supply and lower prices last year)

    • Dirk MacGirk

      You can't judge supply/demand based on the volume traded. So much of the traded volume is related to people trying to play the market rather than just people buying to plex accounts.

  • Barberian

    Due to piss poor planing on CCP's part, many gamers will be forced out, or forced to close alt accounts they have been plexing. Currently and for some time I have been paying for 1 account, and plexing three. With the cost of 3 plex over 1.5b isk, it's just getting to be too much work to keep the extra accounts. With each account I drop, it makes it that much harder to earn isk. With all that said, Eve Online is looking less and less attractive to play.

    Before the Jita riots, CCP had noticed the price of plex's going up. They had said they were aware of it and were looking into "activities" to help stabilize the plex market. That was back when plex was under 300m. Since then CCP has been utterly mute on the topic. With the current trend, I'll be able to buy a supercap with a plex or two soon.

  • Gumpin

    I think its all the new players that flood faction war, get billions of isk orbiting in an atron or condor, and then activate/resub on plex.

    • mararinn

      So get into FW, spin complexes and make your fortune. Quit your bitching, exploit the huge ISK transfer mechanism that CCP has intentionally left wide open. Then you, too, can get all cocky and casual about shipping billions of ISK in one freighter load.

  • Retard

    Suddenly everyone becomes an Economist… if you don't understand the concepts don't act like you do.

  • Raz

    Considering how isk has been losing value in game, the question that should have been made some time ago was why wasn't ISK losing value to real money.

    We simply don't have enought data to know what happended. FW has been arround for long and prices are spiking a lot more in the last 2 weeks. And after the news came on The Mitani seems the prices got even higher. EVENews is giving it's push now. Yes, probably this article will have more effect then the FW isk.

    Interesting would be to know why the overflow of FW items hasn't really crashed the prices for those items market. Wrong perception of value from buyers and seller and incomplete information might be the greatest reasons for the very slow evolution of prices in that area. CCP sure has data for some interesting work on those departments.

    • noiskforme

      if you think how much isk you can get when you buy a plex and then sell it at jita prices. Isk kind of has lost monetary value

  • Troll father

    Good riddens to those people! I hear WoW has a new expansion, if your TOO poor to afford $15 bucks a month get out of your moms basement get eh J O B! Freeloaders need to get with it. Less casuals players to EVE will improve this game over time. The days of the. Semi annual random logon/logoff guy will cease to exsist. So say we all

    • ssad

      So what do you suggest 90% of CFC do then? Get a job? Tsss…. you be funny

      • John Douche

        They will collapse as planned.

        Sitting in a 0.0 blue zone and grinding for the sole purpose to be sitting in a blue zone and to grind for PLEX … is narrow-minded play style and only feels good for some time.

        They have helped PL to make ISKs with Tech moons and then they will be flung away like a used condom. Until the next zerg swarm is bred.

        • ssad

          Im just waiting for HBC to finally turn on goons. Its just a matter of time. Thats when the fun starts.

          • leetnessmonster

            HBC turn on goons???

            HBC is goons south, they would try to destroy every other entity before they turned on goons

            Pets are pets

          • Commentary

            don't hold your breath, but if it does ever happen, the goon pets (Test, PL, etc.) will then have the honor of creating their own coalition and branding themselves accordingly.

          • mararinn

            For HBC to turn on Goons, Test would have to know how to act on their own volition.

            Are they capable of making up their own agenda?

    • Rage

      I will continue to rage about the stupid prick rich fat ass american (I bet you are) who thinks everyone only needs to get a job to afford playing eve! Go out and find a job in other parts of the world! Learn about other societies but your own! Basically stop being a f**king big mouth about money and realize 15$ is a months income in some countries and some people can't afford as much as you!!

      I am fortunate enough to not be one of those people but damn I am ashamed people who have as little knowledge about money and life in general as you are allowed to play computer games!

      Quit eve and go learn about life

      • Troll father

        I do need to I like this side of the pond!

        • Troll Transexual

          Just call me pops!

      • Team Romney

        Stop complaining you lazy democrat. It's not CCCP's job to provide Plex for you at a lousy Lvl 4 mission a day. Go blob a Tech moon moon with a few hundred minions or GTFO. Your poorness is disgusting. At least join CFC so you can help others stay rich.

    • CB/JL

      Lets see here, I make $650 per week, and I have 4 kids, and look after my mother-in-law. School fees, food bill, electricity bill, don't forget fuel for my car, fuel for my wifes car, insurance (car, house and health), it adds up.

      It would be nice to be a teenager again, where all I have to do is work a part time job to pay for eve, while my parents pay for all the things mentioned above on my behalf.

      • Crymeariver

        Perhaps you should have paid more attention in school, that way you'd now have a better job.

        Deal with it.

        • ssad

          You sir, are a fucktard.

          If there is someone that needed to stay in school its you son. Where is the empathy? The guy is simply saying that he has a life outside EVE that means more to him than pixels.

          He, like alot of ppl in eve, play it for the funs to be had and they enjoy it even more when they can use more accounts with ingame plex.

          He is saying that he is sad about the fact that he wont be able to play the game as he used to because of things he cant to anything about.

          He was giving his point of view.

          Deal with it, you lonely basement hoarder you….

        • notamoron

          Cry your own river

    • Smiling Joe

      WoW is subscription based as well ass clown, so that attempt at an insult is laughable. Your insults about jobless being a reason people are irritated over the price of PLEX is also flawed. Those with jobs that do live on their own tend to have more bills, and less time to grind isk. Whereas the jobless tend to have time to i don't know, play video games all day, or scrounge up $15 a month for an account when no bills are owed. Your ignorance is blinding, quite frankly digustingly ignorant.

  • http://evedreams.wordpress.com/ dreamersofreality

    This rise in consistent plex prices is showing what exactly I (and others) said back when the supercap nerf hit. People would buy plexes to get a super, and now with supers unable to defend themselves effectively, just killed that entire market. We wouldn't be having this discussion if supers had been left alone, or had been hard limited to the number of normal drones they could have in there bay.
    Also with each and every passing Alliance Tournament and now this new one thats going to be happening soon. All of which are being paid for (by entry) by plex's, and each time the prices go up. Pre AT9 plex was around 400-450m and stayed there, then AT10 came and prices went into the 500's, and with a new Tourney so soon, plexs will be around 600-700m. Just look at that chart and you can see where the spikes in prices happen.
    As time moves on and these prices keep going up, the game will start to die off as people stop being able to play as they can't pay. Even my goon radar is going off on this one too. If they can't kill your game by blowing you up, then they can kill your game by making you not even able to play the game. Yup, sounds like goons to me.
    These 3 things are combining together to make those prices go up, AT, no supers being bought by plex, and market manipulation are all contributing to making this game go south.

    I may be a crazed lunatic to most…..but then again….I might be right

    • Chicken Little

      Yep! Eve is dying (again)

    • Saiphas Cain

      Yes, that is exactly our plan. Make PLEX so expensive that only GOONS can afford them. No wait… GOONS are all noobs… how could they possibly earn enough per month to afford PLEX? No wait, I've got it! You take a blob of ships and… no, that's not it. I'll get back to you.

      I PLEX and I have PLEXed for probably a year now? I make enough a month to do it and the PLEX always comes before other profit reinvestment. I'm one of the lucky few who can afford subscription prices but… I choose not to. Not because I'm a dick, but because I can. … OK, maybe because I'm a dick too. Point is apparently I'm part of the problem and not part of the solution.

      again

  • https://www.facebook.com/steve.ramos.mdiv Steve Ramos

    Firstly, A plex is loosely based on what an average player's monthly income is in isk. As the playerbase matures, this number goes up.

    Secondly, As isk faucets open (pi, fw, etc.), and the paying playerbase decreases, we're in a hyperinflationary phase. Plex as a concept exists because CCP wanted to exaggerate their playerbase. So it originally encouraged people to get that second account in exchange for some isk grinding. Now, many eve vets do not pay for the game, and those who don't pay are not being replaced at sufficient rate by those who do…

    Plex is the like the price of gold. In a very real way, Plex price is demonstrating inflation just the price of Gold in Dollars does.

    • mararinn

      Your gold analogy is flawed since gold is not a comestible.

      • sammy davis

        The definition of comestible; Fit to be eaten; edible

        Neither gold nor plex are comestible. Maybe your using google translate and this is what it gave you. At any rate I think I understand what your trying to say. Maybe you meant consumable.

        • mararinn

          PLEX is not merely consumable, it is required to keep accounts alive. From the point of view of an EVE Online account, PLEX is indeed food.

          You are not thinking four dimensionally, Marty.

    • dani

      Your statement that PLEX does not pay for the game is WRONG!
      All this plexes are imported in the game, by someone paying for them!

      • sammy davis

        "Your statement that PLEX does not pay for the game is WRONG!"

        I'm really not seeing where he said that.

    • Aher

      Well at least in my case the PLEX has elasticity … after finishing my stock (4 items lol ) i will plex only one account and pay with rl money the other . I wander how many will do like me …

  • Alx Warlord

    You forgot one important thing… there are players that only have 1 ACC and pay it using PLEX… so…

    d) Stop playing…

  • vlad

    i know i had 3 accounts and used to plex them all long, now i droped 2 of thouse 3 for a wile, and plex or pay for my main depends on the month. It hurted my logistics a bit, one was a pi alt the other one was a miner and hauler, not a big loss though, i can keep playing similar as i was before and if i ever need one of my alts i can resurrect them for a month or two (probably not gonna happen untill new year).

  • the vet

    i think eve is broke for a lot of reasons, but wont go into that now

    i dont consider eve is worth paying real money for and with the exploding prices of plex's, i shall quit soon

    i dont understand ccp, they seem to do everything to make eve boring and drive people away

  • mararinn

    Tenet, not tenant.

  • dikreathz

    Plexers, they pay by being in game and plexing adding to the markets and community, they are ussually the more dedicated (or more active players) i myself plex 2 account and pay for 2, at 600mil i bought plex to sell, mining has made me enough to plex well now easily 2bil a month, macks allow for better AFK mining now and I am sure FW has also had a similar effect,

    at the end of the day less ppl are buying plex to sell for isk… subs are cheaper. and there is more ISK in EDEN so prices will fly and when macks are fixed and FW gets the nerf bat there will be less ISK and the market will crash.

    already the news hype has increased the PLEX availible on the market as of last night 2211 plex for sale vs the 3572 or so offers to buy, slowing inflation, but certainly prices will rise again before the next expantion then the market will even out again (at a higher price, plex only ever gains due to cocsistant demand)

    • Terrible Poaster

      macs have *nothing* to do with PLEX prices.

      macs are not ISK faucets. People mine, sell ore for ISK from other players. If there is too much supply, price falls. Look at the isotope market and how it collapsed over last month or so. I'm a little surprised the same didn't happen in mineral market yet, although high ends like zydrine and megacyte collapsed despite of drone droppings.

      • dikreathz

        you are right in say mac do not contribute isk, but to someone like myself have given the ability to mine several chars with less interaction due to large ore hold, this means the level of ISK i now have means i can PLEX, ppl that didnt have that much isk before are now coming into more ISK

        there has been a shift and mining has increased, ore prices have not shifted because if it loers ppl cant plex and thus dont mine. theres a new equilibrium forming there accounting for a small fraction of plexers (but plexers that were not there before)

    • John Douche

      Saying Plexers are the more dedicated and active players is a bit of a joke …

      If they had the money would they less often run after the ISK, but could play EVE in a different way. Each month do they need to dedicate time to making ISK with no real choice if they want to avoid paying for EVE. Some of them spend their weekends mining afk over tens of hours only to get enough ISK in to pay for the next month, while others are having a blast in large fights and destroy large amounts of ISK at the same time.

      • dikreathz

        Well i am capable of paying for all 4 accounts, i choose not to and make more than is needed for the two accounts I use plex for (by blasting rocks), so there are ppl that enjoy grinding, if i wanted boom i would be more active in a null sec alliance, (or playing Supreme commander) difference in high sec and O.o mentallity

        and if you note there has been a huge influx of plex, but demand has remained steady, last night alone i spoke to 6 different ppl all running 3-4 accounts, all high sec all miners, looking at forums ppl are overjoyed about the mackinaw's and thier yield,

  • Dirk MacGirk

    I am going to posit that there is elasticity, but it is elasticity of supply. Prices for plex are the most market driven in the game and are based almost exclusively on actual supply and demand factors and the market is liquid enough to avoid massive attempts at manipulation. My belief is that the demand side for plex remains generally steady with a slight upward bias. The subscriber base doesnt seem to be growing very much and there is no real need to buy more plex than needed to fund accounts for more than a month or two. Obviously events like the tournament, power of two, vid cards and the like will temporarily increase demand. But hoarding of future game time is unlikely, especially during a period when plex prices are moving sharply higher. Buyers tend to buy tome as needed and are unlikely to store up when chances are the price will come down or at least moderate.

    However, the supply side is what I believe is truly driving the price. There is simply not enough plex coming into the game to satisfy existing demand. I know that sounds simple – supply lags demand and price increases. But all things being equal, the simple explanation is most often correct. One would think that with plex above 600 that this would induce more players to buy isk with real money, this leading to an increase in supply in game. But given the current economic conditions in the real world, coupled with (perhaps) fewer players looking to plex that shiny new super, the supply just isn't materializing.

  • Just Bob

    I think lots of things have an influence on the price.
    FW(and Incursions in the past)
    AURUM
    Turny now require PLEX
    Overall everyone over time starting to learn how to make money themselves.
    World Econ generally down(less people selling PLEX)
    I also get the impression that the EVE player base has grown a little bit(Publicity from dust actually has brought people over)
    Few people can just stop paying for accounts with PLEX, they need and want all the accounts to have fun in game, and make money easier. Some people will stop using PLEX for their account, but most people who want to continue to play, will have to continue to pay( Inelasticity )
    So pretty much the things mentioned here.
    Yeah I can honestly see GOONS fucking with the price, but I dont actually think they are.

  • Terrible Poaster

    People use PLEX to buy game time are in 2 camps,

    * unable to pay for game (I suspect very small minority)
    * unwilling to spend more $$$ on the game

    I'm squarely in the latter corner. I haven't paid for Eve for years (since 32-day GT existed and cost was 120m ISK). As price of PLEX went up and CCP changed with war mechanics, I simply abandoned some alts. So yes, PLEX prices are elastic, but to make EVE impossible to pay with PLEX, the price would need to go past about 2B ISK. And by that time, there will be other problems quite evident.

  • meskia

    i hope the plex prices goes up even more , good thing all those pesties alts are closing. more iskies when sell plex

  • gary

    you are completely IGNORING the option players have just opting NOT to buy a PLEX at all. No one is forcing anyo9ne to play EVE or running all the their accounts every single month.I have 3 active account I fund on a regular basis and have access to or occasionally fund 2 others. I fund them based on my involved in Eve at that time and what specific activities ingame I am involved with. Sometimne I am just too busy in RL to play Eve at all and they all get idled.